High-Protein Creamy Buffalo Chicken Pasta

Your New Favorite Dinner is Here: High-Protein Creamy Buffalo Chicken Pasta

Hey, friend! Isla here. Can I tell you a secret? I live for those moments when a craving hits so hard, it’s all you can think about. For me, that craving is almost always a toss-up between two things: the spicy, tangy punch of buffalo sauce and the ultimate comfort of a big, creamy bowl of pasta. For the longest time, I thought I had to choose. A healthy(ish) buffalo chicken salad or a decadent, curl-up-on-the-couch pasta. But what if I told you that the universe, in its infinite wisdom (and with a little nudge from my kitchen experiments), decided to bring these two soulmates together?

Welcome to the dish that has single-handedly solved my weeknight dinner dilemmas and become a regular request from friends and family: my High-Protein Creamy Buffalo Chicken Pasta. This isn’t just another pasta recipe. This is a feel-good, flavor-BOMB that manages to be indulgent, spicy, creamy, and surprisingly fit-friendly all at once. We’re talking tender shredded chicken, protein-packed pasta, and a sauce that’s so luxuriously creamy you won’t believe it’s lightened up. It’s the hero your busy week needs, ready in about 25 minutes, and guaranteed to make you do a little happy dance right there by the stove. So, grab your favorite skillet and let’s make some magic!

The Night We Fell in Love with Buffalo Everything

My love affair with buffalo flavor started not in a fancy restaurant, but on a sticky, laughter-filled summer night during a family vacation. My dad, convinced he was a grill master, decided to host a “wing night” for the whole extended family. Picture this: a folding table covered in a red-checkered vinyl cloth, citronella candles flickering, and a stack of napkins so high it could have been a skyscraper. Dad’s wings were… well, let’s just say they were enthusiastically charred. But it was the sauce that saved the day—a big, bubbling pot of Frank’s RedHot and butter that my uncle kept whisking, its vinegary, spicy aroma filling the air.

We dunked everything in that sauce—the wings, sure, but also celery sticks, carrot batons, and even the crusty bread my grandma brought. Our fingers were stained orange, and our lips were on fire, but we were so, so happy. That sauce became a symbol of unpretentious, joy-filled eating for me. This pasta dish is my homage to that night. It captures that same bold, communal spirit but in a cozy, one-bowl format that’s perfect for a Tuesday night in. It’s the taste of a happy memory, with a few extra grams of protein thrown in for good measure.

Print

Gathering Your Flavor Crew: The Ingredients

This recipe is all about smart, simple ingredients that work overtime. Here’s what you’ll need and why each one is a rockstar in this dish.

• 8 oz Protein Pasta (Penne or Rotini): I’m a huge fan of using protein pasta (made from chickpeas, lentils, or edamame) here because it adds a serious nutritional boost and holds onto the creamy sauce beautifully. Chef’s Insight: The shape matters! Penne and rotini have all those nooks and crannies that trap the sauce in every single bite.
• 1 lb Cooked, Shredded Chicken Breast: The ultimate weeknight shortcut. I often use a rotisserie chicken to save time, or I’ll quickly poach or bake a couple of breasts on a Sunday for easy meal prep. Substitution Tip: For a different flavor, shredded turkey works wonderfully, or for a vegetarian twist, canned chickpeas (rinsed and drained) are fantastic!
• ½ cup Plain Greek Yogurt: This is our secret weapon for creaminess and protein without the guilt. It adds a slight tang that plays so nicely with the buffalo sauce. Chef’s Insight: Make sure it’s plain and not vanilla (a mistake you only make once, trust me!). Full-fat will be richer, but non-fat works perfectly too.
• ¼ cup Buffalo Hot Sauce (like Frank’s RedHot): The star of the show! Frank’s is my go-to because it has the perfect balance of heat and vinegary tang. Substitution Tip: Feel free to use your favorite brand, but I’d steer clear of super-vinegary sauces like Tabasco for this, as they can overpower the creaminess.
• ¼ cup Light Cream Cheese or Neufchâtel, softened: This is what gives the sauce its lush, velvety body. Let it sit out for 15-20 minutes before you start cooking so it blends in seamlessly. Substitution Tip: You can use full-fat cream cheese for an extra-indulgent version, or for a dairy-free option, Kite Hill’s plain almond milk cream cheese is a great substitute.
• ½ cup Reduced-Fat Shredded Cheddar: A little cheesy goodness for that melt-y, gooey factor. Chef’s Insight: I prefer to shred my own from a block as it melts smoother, but pre-shredded works in a pinch!
• 2 Cloves Garlic, minced: The flavor foundation. Fresh is best here—that quick sauté in the pan makes the entire kitchen smell incredible.
• Salt & Pepper to taste: The essential flavor enhancers. Don’t be shy!
• Green Onions or Parsley for garnish (optional): A pop of fresh color and flavor to finish the dish. The cool, crisp green onion is a perfect contrast to the spicy sauce.

Let’s Get Cooking: Your Foolproof Steps to Buffalo Bliss

Okay, team! This is where the magic happens. It’s a simple process, but I’ve packed each step with my favorite little hacks to ensure your pasta is absolutely perfect.

1. Cook the Pasta & Save the Water!Bring a large pot of salted water to a rolling boil and cook your protein pasta according to the package directions. Now, here’s a non-negotiable Chef’s Hack: Before you drain it, use a mug or ladle to reserve about ¼ cup of that starchy, magical pasta water. This liquid gold is the key to making your sauce silky and helping it cling to the pasta. Once drained, set the pasta aside.
2. Sauté the Aromatics.While the pasta is cooking, grab a large skillet and place it over medium heat. You can use a tiny bit of olive oil or a quick spritz of cooking spray. Add your minced garlic and sauté for just 60-90 seconds until it’s incredibly fragrant. Watch it closely! We’re toasting it, not burning it. Burnt garlic turns bitter, and we want pure, savory goodness.
3. Create the Dreamy Sauce.Reduce the heat to low. To the skillet with the garlic, add your buffalo hot sauce, softened cream cheese, and Greek yogurt. Now, grab your whisk (or a fork in a pinch) and whisk, whisk, whisk until the sauce is completely smooth and homogenous. This is the moment it all comes together! If it seems a little thick, don’t panic. We have our secret weapon—the pasta water—waiting in the wings.
4. Bring the Family Together.Add your shredded chicken and the cooked pasta to the skillet. Use a large spoon or tongs to toss everything together, ensuring every piece of chicken and pasta is lovingly coated in that creamy buffalo sauce. If the sauce is too thick for your liking, now is the time to add a splash of that reserved pasta water, one tablespoon at a time, until it reaches your perfect saucy consistency.
5. The Cheesy Finish.Sprinkle in your shredded cheddar cheese and give everything one final, gentle toss. Let it heat through for another minute or two, just until the cheese has melted into the sauce, creating little cheesy ribbons throughout. The smell at this point is going to be absolutely irresistible.
6. Garnish and Serve Immediately!Take the skillet off the heat. Divide the pasta into bowls and top with a generous sprinkle of chopped green onions or parsley. This adds a fresh, bright note that cuts through the richness perfectly. Now, dig in!

How to Serve This Flavor Wave

This pasta is a complete meal in a bowl, but I love to lean into the whole buffalo wing experience when serving it. For a truly epic dinner, I’ll serve it with a side of crisp celery sticks and carrot batons for dipping and crunching between bites. If you’re feeling extra, a small cup of extra cool, creamy ranch or blue cheese dressing for drizzling (or dunking!) is a game-changer. It’s all about that hot-and-cool contrast that makes your taste buds sing!

Ride the Wave Your Way: Recipe Variations

One of my core beliefs is that recipes are meant to be played with! Here are a few ways to make this dish your own:

• “Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese” Style: Swap the protein pasta for elbow macaroni and stir in an extra ½ cup of shredded cheese right at the end for the ultimate comfort food mashup.
• Veggie-Packed Power Bowl: Sauté a cup of chopped spinach or kale right after the garlic, or stir in a cup of steamed broccoli florets with the chicken to get your greens in.
• Blue Cheese Lover’s Dream: Swap the cheddar cheese for crumbled blue cheese. The bold, funky flavor is a classic pairing with buffalo sauce.
• Dairy-Free Delight: Use the dairy-free cream cheese substitute mentioned earlier and a vegan cheddar shred. The sauce will still be incredibly creamy and delicious.
• Extra Fiery Kick: For my heat-seekers, add a teaspoon of sriracha, a pinch of cayenne pepper, or even a diced jalapeño to the sauce when you’re sautéing the garlic.

Isla’s Chef Notes & Kitchen Confessions

This recipe has been through so many iterations in my kitchen! The first time I made it, I used a full cup of heavy cream and felt like I needed a nap afterward. It was delicious, but not exactly the weeknight warrior I was hoping for. The Greek yogurt and light cream cheese swap was a total lightbulb moment—it kept the creaminess but left me feeling energized and satisfied, not sluggish.

A funny kitchen story? I once was filming a reel for this recipe and was so busy chatting to the camera that I completely forgot to add the chicken! I poured the finished, beautiful pasta into a bowl, looked at it, and went, “…wait a minute. What’s missing?” We had a good laugh, and I just stirred it in at the end. It was a great reminder that even when things don’t go perfectly, the food is still almost always delicious. No stress, remember? That’s the BiteTide way!

Your Questions, Answered!

I’ve gotten so many DMs and comments about this pasta (which I LOVE!), so here are answers to the most common questions.

• My sauce is too thin! How can I thicken it up?No worries, this is an easy fix! Let the pasta sit in the skillet over low heat for another 2-3 minutes, stirring occasionally. The sauce will naturally reduce and thicken. If you’re still in a pinch, you can make a quick slurry by mixing 1 teaspoon of cornstarch with 1 tablespoon of cold water and stirring it into the sauce. It should thicken up within a minute.
• My sauce is too thick and gloppy. Help!This is exactly why we save that pasta water! Add it back in, one tablespoon at a time, while tossing the pasta over low heat. The starch in the water will help loosen the sauce without making it watery. If you’ve already discarded it, a splash of regular milk or chicken broth will also work.
• Can I make this creamy buffalo chicken pasta ahead of time?You can, but a heads-up: the pasta will continue to absorb the sauce as it sits. I recommend making the sauce and cooking the pasta, but storing them separately in the fridge for up to 2 days. When you’re ready to eat, reheat the sauce gently in a skillet, add the pasta, and splash in a little water or milk to bring it back to life. It’s best fresh, but still totally tasty as leftovers!
• Is this dish really spicy?It has a definite kick, but the cream cheese and Greek yogurt do a fantastic job of mellowing out the heat, making it a manageable, flavorful spice rather than a five-alarm fire. If you’re sensitive to spice, start with 2 tablespoons of buffalo sauce and add more to taste. For kids, you could even use a mild wing sauce.

Nutritional Information*

*Please note: This is an estimate based on the specific ingredients listed and may vary depending on the brands you use.

Per Serving (Serves 4): Calories: 420 | Protein: 38g | Carbs: 28g | Fat: 18g | Fiber: 4g | Sugar: 3g

Well, that’s it, my friend! You are now fully equipped to conquer this creamy, spicy, protein-packed masterpiece. I am so excited for you to try it. When you do, please please please tag me on Instagram @BiteTide or pin it on Pinterest so I can see your beautiful creations! Now, go forth and ride that flavor wave.

With love and a well-seasoned skillet,

Isla 💛