Your New Favorite Comfort Food is Here (And It’s Lighter Than You Think!)
Hey, friend! Isla here from BiteTide. Let’s talk about cravings. You know the ones I mean. That deep, undeniable pull towards something creamy, cheesy, and gloriously comforting. But then, that little voice in your head chimes in about being… well, good. Ugh. It’s a culinary standoff that can ruin a perfectly good mood.
What if I told you you don’t have to choose? What if you could have a dinner that feels like a big, warm hug but doesn’t leave you feeling weighed down? Enter the hero of our story today: my Lightened-Up Buffalo Chicken Penne Bake.
This isn’t just another pasta bake. This is a flavor EXPERIENCE. We’re talking tender penne pasta and juicy shredded chicken, all swirled in a sauce that’s magically both creamy and tangy with that classic buffalo kick. The secret? We’re ditching the heavy, calorie-laden cream and butter-based sauces and embracing the power of protein-packed Greek yogurt. It creates the most luxuriously creamy base that clings to every noodle, all while keeping things bright and balanced. Topped with a blanket of bubbly, golden mozzarella, this bake is the ultimate weeknight winner. It’s the dish that will have your family asking for seconds, your friends begging for the recipe, and you doing a little happy dance because it all comes together in about 40 minutes, with most of that being hands-off oven time. So, let’s turn up the oven and turn down the dinnertime drama. Your flavor wave is waiting.
The Night We Fell in Love with Buffalo Everything
This recipe has a special place in my heart, and it all goes back to a ridiculously chaotic, fun, and sauce-splattered Sunday years ago. My best friends and I had crammed into my tiny apartment kitchen to watch the big game. The menu was a classic spread of wings, celery sticks, and blue cheese dip. The problem? We had one vegetarian, one person avoiding fried food, and a general mess of plates and sticky fingers.
In a moment of “what do we have in the fridge?” inspiration, I decided to deconstruct the whole experience. I tossed some leftover shredded roast chicken with buffalo sauce, mixed it with penne and a tub of Greek yogurt (desperate times!), threw it in a dish with the last of my mozzarella, and hoped for the best. The result was pure magic. It was the essence of everything we loved about game day—the heat, the cool creaminess, the community—all baked into one glorious, shareable dish. No bones, no fuss, just pure, unadulterated joy. From that day on, this bake became our official “gather-around” meal. It’s a reminder that the best recipes aren’t always planned; sometimes, they’re born from a little chaos and a whole lot of love.
Print
Buffalo Chicken Penne Bake : Creamy, Spicy & Oven-Ready
- Total Time: 40 minutes
- Yield: 6 servings 1x
Description
This Buffalo Chicken Penne Bake delivers creamy heat without the heaviness. Made with a light buffalo sauce blended with Greek yogurt, tender shredded chicken, and gooey mozzarella, it’s the perfect balance of bold flavor and comfort. Baked until bubbly and golden, it’s a crowd-pleasing dinner with a lighter touch.
Ingredients
12 oz (340g) penne pasta
2 cups cooked, shredded chicken
½ cup buffalo sauce (adjust to heat preference)
¾ cup plain Greek yogurt (2% or full-fat)
1 cup shredded mozzarella cheese
¼ cup grated Parmesan (optional)
2 tablespoons chopped green onions (optional)
Salt and black pepper to taste
Optional: crumbled blue cheese, extra hot sauce for topping
Instructions
Preheat oven to 375°F (190°C). Lightly grease a 9×13-inch baking dish.
Cook penne in salted water until al dente. Drain and set aside.
In a large bowl, whisk together buffalo sauce and Greek yogurt until smooth. Stir in chicken, cooked pasta, and half of the mozzarella. Season with salt and pepper.
Pour mixture into baking dish and top with remaining mozzarella and Parmesan.
Bake uncovered for 20–25 minutes, until hot and bubbly.
Garnish with green onions, blue cheese, or extra hot sauce if desired.
- Prep Time: 15 minutes
- Cook Time: 25 minutes
- Category: Dinner, Main Course
- Cuisine: American
Nutrition
- Calories: 420
- Carbohydrates: 30g
- Protein: 32g
Gathering Your Flavor Crew: The Ingredients
Ready to build this beauty? Here’s your grocery list. The magic of this recipe is in its flexibility, so I’ve packed each item with my favorite chef insights and swaps.
- 12 oz (340g) Penne Pasta: Penne is our MVP here—those little tubes are perfect for catching all the creamy, spicy sauce. Feel free to swap for rigatoni, ziti, or even cavatappi! Pro tip: we’re cooking it al dente (meaning it still has a slight bite) because it will soften up a bit more in the oven.
- 2 cups Cooked, Shredded Chicken: This is your chance to be a kitchen efficiency expert! Use a rotisserie chicken from the store, leftover grilled chicken, or even some boiled and shredded chicken breasts. It’s a fantastic way to reduce food waste and get dinner on the table faster.
- ½ cup Buffalo Sauce: The star of the show! I’m a Frank’s RedHot devotee, but use your favorite. This amount gives you a solid medium heat. If your crew is spice-shy, start with ⅓ cup. For the heat seekers, go for a full ¾ cup and thank me later.
- ¾ cup Plain Greek Yogurt (2% or Full-Fat): Our healthy hack! Using full-fat or 2% Greek yogurt gives you the creamiest result and prevents the sauce from splitting. Please avoid non-fat if you can—it can sometimes get a bit grainy when heated. This is what lightens up the dish without sacrificing that rich, creamy texture we crave.
- 1 cup Shredded Mozzarella Cheese: The gooey, glorious blanket on top. I like to shred a block of low-moisture mozzarella myself, as the pre-shredded bags often have anti-caking agents that can make the melt less smooth. But hey, in a pinch, the bagged stuff works just fine!
- ¼ cup Grated Parmesan (Optional): This is our flavor booster! It adds a salty, nutty depth that takes the sauce to the next level. Highly recommended, but if you don’t have it, no sweat.
- 2 tablespoons Chopped Green Onions (Optional): For a fresh, bright pop of color and flavor right at the end.
- Salt and Black Pepper to Taste: Don’t forget to season! Taste your mixture before it goes in the oven.
- Optional Toppers: Crumbled blue cheese is the classic buffalo wing partner—a little sprinkle on top is divine. Extra hot sauce for the brave, and extra green onions for that garden-fresh finish.
Let’s Get Cooking: Your Step-by-Step Guide to Baked Bliss
Okay, team! Aprons on, let’s do this. I’ll walk you through each step with my favorite little hacks to ensure your bake is absolutely perfect.
- Preheat and Prep: First things first, get that oven roaring to 375°F (190°C). While it’s heating up, lightly grease your 9×13-inch baking dish with a little butter, oil, or cooking spray. This is your insurance policy for easy, beautiful serving later. No one wants to leave half the cheesy crust stuck to the pan!
- Pasta Perfection: Bring a large pot of generously salted water to a rolling boil. You want the water to taste like the sea—this is your one chance to season the pasta from the inside out! Cook the penne according to the package directions, but shave a minute or two off the time. We want it al dente because it’s going to continue cooking and soaking up sauce in the oven. Drain it well, but no need to rinse—that starchy surface helps the sauce cling on for dear life.
- Create the Magic Sauce: This is where the transformation happens! In a large mixing bowl (big enough to hold everything), grab a whisk and combine the buffalo sauce and Greek yogurt. Whisk it until it’s completely smooth and one gorgeous, creamy orange color. Chef’s Hack: Let the Greek yogurt sit on the counter for 10-15 minutes before you start. Taking the chill off helps it blend more smoothly and prevents any curdling.
- The Big Mix-Off: Now, add your drained penne, shredded chicken, and half of that glorious mozzarella cheese right into the bowl with your sauce. Oh, and the Parmesan too, if you’re using it! Grab a big spoon or spatula and gently fold everything together until every single piece of pasta and chicken is coated in that creamy buffalo goodness. This is the time to taste it! Does it need a pinch more salt? A crack of black pepper? Adjust to your heart’s content.
- Bake to Bubbly Glory: Pour the entire mixture into your prepared baking dish and spread it out into an even layer. Now, shower the top with the remaining half of the mozzarella cheese. This creates that iconic, irresistible golden-brown crust. Pop it into the preheated oven, uncovered, for 20-25 minutes. You’re looking for the edges to be gently bubbling and the cheese on top to be fully melted, spotted with gorgeous golden-brown bits.
- The Final Touch: Once it’s out of the oven, let it sit for about 5 minutes. I know, it’s torture, but this rest time allows the sauce to set just a little, making it easier to serve beautiful, clean portions. Then, go to town with your garnishes! A flurry of green onions, a generous crumbling of blue cheese, or an extra drizzle of hot sauce makes it picture-perfect.
How to Serve This Masterpiece
This bake is a star all on its own, but a little styling goes a long way! I love serving it right from the baking dish at the table for that cozy, family-style vibe. Use a big spoon or a serving spatula to dish out hearty portions. To balance the creamy, spicy heat, I always serve it with a simple, crisp side. A big green salad with a sharp vinaigrette, some extra celery sticks and carrot sticks (to keep the buffalo wing theme going!), or even some garlic bread for the carb enthusiasts in your life. It’s the perfect, complete meal that feels special but was secretly a breeze to make.
Ride Your Own Flavor Wave: Recipe Variations
This recipe is your canvas! Get creative and make it your own. Here are a few of my favorite twists:
- “Ranch” It Up: Swap half the buffalo sauce for ¼ cup of ranch dressing mixed into the yogurt sauce. It’s a next-level creamy, herby situation.
- Veggie Power: Sauté some chopped celery and red onion and mix it in with the pasta. Or stir in a few handfuls of fresh spinach—it wilts perfectly into the hot sauce.
- Make it Meatless: Use two cans of drained and rinsed chickpeas or a plant-based chicken alternative for a fantastic vegetarian version.
- Extra Cheesy & Creamy: Stir in 4 oz of softened cream cheese along with the Greek yogurt for an ultra-decadent, velvety sauce.
- Gluten-Free Friendly: Simply swap the penne for your favorite gluten-free pasta. The sauce works like a charm with any variety.
Isla’s Chef Notes & Kitchen Confessions
This recipe has been a living, evolving thing in my kitchen. The first time I made it, I was so worried the yogurt would curdle that I stood peering through the oven door the entire time. Spoiler alert: it didn’t! The key is mixing it smoothly with the buffalo sauce and not over-baking it. Over the years, I’ve learned that this is the ultimate “clean out the fridge” dish. Got a lone chicken breast? Some leftover turkey? A half-used tub of yogurt? This bake welcomes them all with open arms.
One of my favorite kitchen memories is of my nephew, who claimed to “hate spicy food,” devouring two helpings and then asking if we could have it every week. It just goes to show that the heat is totally manageable and the creamy factor is a total crowd-pleaser. Don’t be afraid to make this recipe your own—that’s where the real magic happens!
Your Questions, Answered: FAQs & Troubleshooting
I’ve made this bake a zillion times and have answered just as many questions from the BiteTide community. Here are the most common ones to help you out!
Q: My sauce seemed a bit watery after baking. What happened?
A: This can happen for a couple of reasons! The most common culprit is the pasta being a bit too wet when you mix it. Make sure you drain it really well. Also, using a Greek yogurt with a lower fat content can sometimes release more water. Finally, make sure your chicken is thoroughly cooked and not retaining any extra moisture. If it happens, don’t panic! Just let it rest for 10 minutes after baking—it will thicken up as it cools slightly.
Q: Can I make this Buffalo Chicken Penne Bake ahead of time?
A: Absolutely! You are a meal prep genius. Assemble the entire dish right up to the point of baking, cover it tightly, and refrigerate for up to 24 hours. When you’re ready, you may need to add 5-10 minutes to the baking time since it’s going into the oven cold. You can also freeze the unbaked casserole for up to 3 months. Thaw it in the fridge overnight before baking.
Q: I’m sensitive to spice. How can I tone down the heat?
A: No problem at all! Start by reducing the buffalo sauce to ⅓ cup. You can also look for a “mild” buffalo sauce at the store. Another great trick is to increase the Greek yogurt by another ¼ cup to add more creamy balance. Taste your sauce mixture before adding the pasta and chicken—you should love it at every stage!
Q: Why can’t I use non-fat Greek yogurt?
A: You technically *can*, but I don’t recommend it for the best texture. Non-fat yogurt has a different protein structure and is more prone to separating and becoming grainy when heated. The bit of fat in 2% or full-fat yogurt helps create a stable, smooth, and luxuriously creamy sauce that mimics the richness of a heavy cream-based one.
Quick Nutrition & Prep Details
Prep Time: 15 minutes | Cook Time: 25 minutes | Total Time: 40 minutes | Servings: 6
Estimated per serving:
Calories: ~420 | Protein: ~32g | Carbs: ~30g | Fat: ~18g | Fiber: ~2g
Please note: Nutritional information is a rough estimate and can vary based on the specific ingredients you use.
This lightened-up buffalo chicken penne bake proves you don’t have to sacrifice flavor to make a cozy, satisfying meal. With its creamy sauce, tender pasta, and just the right kick of heat, it’s a dependable dish you’ll reach for again and again. Pop it in the oven, serve it hot, and watch it disappear!
