Butter Chicken with Chili Butter Drizzle

Butter Chicken with a Fiery Twist? Yes, Please!

Hey there, flavor adventurer! Isla here from BiteTide, waving my wooden spoon from my (probably slightly messy) kitchen. Ever crave something that hugs your soul while giving your taste buds a standing ovation? That’s exactly what this Butter Chicken with Chili Butter Drizzle does. Picture this: succulent chicken swimming in a creamy, spiced coconut-tomato sauce, then crowned with a sizzling, aromatic chili butter that crackles as it hits the surface. It’s cozy, bold, and ridiculously satisfying—like your favorite sweater decided to throw a flavor party.

Now, I know traditional butter chicken is sacred territory. But here at BiteTide? We ride flavor waves. My twist adds that warm, toasty chili butter finish that elevates every bite from “yum” to “WHERE have you been all my life?!” And guess what? It’s still weeknight-friendly. No fancy techniques, no obscure ingredients—just big, unapologetic flavor that comes together faster than you can say “pass the naan.”

Whether you’re feeding a hungry crew, meal-prepping like a boss, or treating yourself to a solo feast (no judgment—I’ve eaten this straight from the pot), this recipe is your golden ticket. It’s the culinary equivalent of a high-five. So tie on your apron, crank up your favorite tunes, and let’s make magic happen. Trust me, that chili butter drizzle? It’s about to become your kitchen’s MVP.

Print

The Night the Chili Butter Saved Dinner (and My Ego)

Let me take you back to last winter. My bestie Lou was visiting, and I was determined to impress her with my “famous” butter chicken. Spoiler: it flopped. Hard. I’d accidentally doubled the cayenne (blame the wine and my chaotic spice drawer), turning it into a tear-inducing inferno. Panic mode! As Lou laughed and fanned her mouth, I spotted a stick of butter and some lonely chili flakes on the counter. Hail Mary moment: I melted them together and drizzled it over the overspiced chicken. The heat transformed—instead of harsh, it became warm, nutty, and complex. Lou took one bite, eyes wide: “Isla, this is BETTER than your original!” Cue my happy dance. That happy accident? It’s now the star of this recipe. Proof that kitchen disasters can birth something spectacular!

Gather Your Flavor Arsenal

Pro Tip: Marinate the chicken overnight for maximum tenderness! Serves 8–10 (perfect for leftovers).

Chicken Marinade

• 4 lbs boneless chicken breasts or thighs → Thighs are juicier! Breasts work but don’t skip the marinating time.
• ½ cup plain Greek yogurt → Tenderizes like a dream. Sub: regular yogurt or coconut yogurt for dairy-free.
• 12 cloves garlic, chopped → Yes, 12! Garlic is the soul here. Pre-minced works in a pinch.
• 4 tbsp fresh grated ginger → Adds bright zing. Powdered ginger? Use 1.5 tbsp.
• 4 tbsp garam masala → The spice blend hero. No sub—grab it online or at any grocery store!
• 4 tsp cumin → Earthy depth. Toast seeds & grind them fresh if you’re extra.
• 2 tsp turmeric → Golden color + anti-inflammatory bonus. Mess alert: stains everything!
• 2–4 tsp cayenne pepper → Heat level’s your call! Start low—you’ll add more later.
• Salt and black pepper → Season like you mean it—1.5 tsp salt minimum.

Sauce & Finish

• 8 tbsp salted butter → Richness base. Unsalted works (add extra salt).
• 2 large yellow onions, chopped → Sweetness foundation. Chop fine for smoother sauce.
• 2 cans (14 oz. each) full-fat coconut milk → Creamy magic! Light coconut milk makes a thinner sauce.
• 1 cup tomato paste → Concentrated umami. Sub: 2 cups tomato sauce + simmer longer.
• 4 tbsp cold salted butter, sliced → Swirled in at the end for glossy luxury. Don’t skip!
• 4 tbsp sesame seeds → Nutty crunch. Toast them first for extra oomph.
• 1 cup fresh cilantro, chopped → Fresh finish. Hate cilantro? Use parsley or basil.

Chili Butter Drizzle

• 6 tbsp salted butter → Melted goodness. Ghee works beautifully too.
• 2 tsp chili flakes → Adjust to your heat love! Korean gochugaru adds fruity notes.
• 1 tsp paprika → Smoked paprika? Yes! Adds subtle campfire vibes.

To Serve

• Steamed rice and warm naan → Sauce-soaking essentials! Try coconut rice for fun.

Let’s Build Flavor, Step by Delicious Step

Total Time: 55 mins (plus marinating) | Active Time: 20 mins

Step 1: Marinate the Chicken (1 hour – overnight)

In a large bowl, combine chicken with yogurt, garlic, ginger, garam masala, cumin, turmeric, cayenne, salt, and pepper. Massage it like you’re kneading stress away! Cover and refrigerate. Chef’s Hack: Use a zip-top bag—less mess, and you can squish it around before cooking!

Step 2: Cook the Base (10 mins)

In a heavy pot (I love my Dutch oven!), melt 8 tbsp butter over medium heat. Add onions and sauté 5–7 mins until golden and sweet. Don’t rush this—caramelized onions = flavor gold! Stir in tomato paste and cook 3–4 mins until it deepens to brick red. Watch it like a hawk—tomato paste burns fast! Add marinated chicken (scrape in every last bit of that marinade!) and sear 4–5 mins until lightly browned but not cooked through.

Step 3: Simmer to Perfection (25–30 mins)

Pour in coconut milk, scraping the pot bottom to release any tasty bits. Bring to a gentle boil, then reduce heat to a simmer (bubbles should lazily break the surface). Cook uncovered 25–30 mins, stirring occasionally, until chicken is tender and sauce thickens. Chef’s Secret: If sauce gets too thick, splash in ¼ cup water or broth. Turn off heat. Stir in cold butter slices until melted and glossy—this makes the sauce restaurant-level luxurious. Fold in sesame seeds.

Step 4: Make the Chili Butter (3 mins)

In a small pan, melt butter with chili flakes and paprika over low heat. Swirl 2–3 mins until fragrant and the butter turns a vibrant red-orange. Immediately remove from heat—burnt chili butter is sad butter.

Step 5: Finish & Feast (5 mins)

Drizzle that gorgeous chili butter over the chicken. Listen to it sizzle—that’s the sound of victory! Scatter cilantro on top. Serve piping hot over steamed rice with warm naan for dipping. Pro move: Put extra chili butter in a bowl for drizzling at the table!

Serving Up the Good Vibes

This dish is all about abundance and color! Scoop fluffy basmati rice into wide, shallow bowls. Ladle the butter chicken over it, letting that sunset-orange sauce pool around the rice. Drizzle extra chili butter in zigzags over the top—let those red sesame seeds pop! Garnish with cilantro confetti. Essential sidekick: Warm, buttery naan for swiping through every drop of sauce. For a fun twist, serve with quick-pickled red onions or cucumber raita to cut the richness. Family-style is my jam—plonk the pot in the center and let everyone dig in!

Make It Your Own: 5 Tasty Twists

• Veggie Power: Swap chicken for 4 lbs cubed cauliflower + chickpeas. Marinate 30 mins. Simmer 15 mins.
• Creamy Dreamy (Dairy-Free): Use coconut yogurt in marinade + vegan butter. Skip cold butter finish—stir in ¼ cup cashew cream instead.
• Seafood Surprise: Use jumbo shrimp or scallops! Marinate 20 mins, sear quickly, and simmer just 5–8 mins.
• Mango Tango: Add 1 cup diced mango with the coconut milk for sweet heat.
• Meal-Prep Magic: Freeze portions without rice. Reheat gently + add fresh chili butter drizzle.

Isla’s Insider Scoop

This recipe? It’s my kitchen’s phoenix rising from the ashes of that cayenne disaster! Over time, I’ve tweaked it based on reader feedback (shout-out to Brian from Idaho who suggested sesame seeds—genius!). The coconut milk was a game-changer; my grandma used heavy cream, but coconut adds silkiness without heaviness. Funny story: My toddler once “helped” by dumping in extra chili flakes. We called it “Dragon Chicken” and it was a hit! Moral: Don’t fear adjustments. This dish is resilient—like your spirit after a long day. Make it spicy, make it mild, but always make it with joy. Oh, and double the chili butter. Always.

Your Questions, Answered!

Q: Can I use chicken thighs instead of breasts?
A: Absolutely! Thighs are my favorite—juicier and more forgiving if you overcook. Just trim excess fat.

Q: My sauce is too thin! Help!
A: No sweat! Simmer uncovered 5–10 mins longer. If still thin, mix 1 tbsp cornstarch + 2 tbsp cold water, stir in, and simmer 2 mins. Too thick? Add splash of broth.

Q: Can I make this ahead?
A: Yes! It tastes even better next day. Cook fully (minus chili butter and cilantro). Cool, refrigerate 3 days or freeze 3 months. Reheat gently + add fresh drizzle/garnish.

Q: Is coconut milk essential? I hate coconut flavor.
A: The coconut mellows into creaminess—you won’t taste “piña colada”! But if wary, sub heavy cream or full-fat evaporated milk.

Nutritional Info (Per Serving)

Calories: 610 | Fat: 45g | Protein: 38g | Carbs: 10g | Net Carbs: 8g
Note: Estimates include ½ cup rice per serving. Use cauliflower rice to lower carbs!

This Butter Chicken with Chili Butter Drizzle is the perfect blend of creamy comfort and fiery flair. Simple enough for weeknights yet impressive for gatherings, it delivers bold flavor with every bite. Pair it with rice or naan, and you’ve got a dish that’s guaranteed to wow both family and guests alike.